Thursday, June 14, 2012

Commentary Summary by Condaci Crittenden


Beowulf a Great Warrior and King
            Beowulf has been called many names for being a great warrior. He has defeated many sea creatures and has always been loyal to the Geats. Beowulf is a study of kingship. Many people agree that he was a great warrior, but not a good king. Beowulf fought hard for his people and had the qualities of a good king. This made him a great warrior and king.
            Beowulf is at least in part a study of kingship. He was well known throughout the whole country and was labeled as mighty and powerful. “In his day, he was the mightiest man on earth, highborn and powerful” (Heaney 197). Beowulf showed many attributes of a good king by being a leader. “Whilst he moved about like the leader he was, enlisting men, the best he could find” (Heaney 205). He was eager to go to the aid of lord Hrothgar and fight Grendel the sea dragon. “I meant to perform to the uttermost what your people wanted or perish in the attempt…” (Heaney 635). This courageous action represents a great warrior and king. Beowulf showed qualities of a good king before he became one and was recognized by lord Hrothgar. “Nowhere, they said, north or south between the two seas or under the tall sky…was there anyone better to raise a shield or to rule a kingdom” (Heaney 860).  Beowulf was a great warrior who attributed qualities of a king and that is why he was, later, named king of the Geats.
            Beowulf has faced difficult challenges throughout his life as a warrior and king. His courageous battles with different sea dragons have earned him fame and fortune. “They sang then and played to please the hero, words and music for their warrior prince…” (Heaney 1063). Beowulf was referred to as a hero and that represents a king. After Beowulf became king, he was still recognized as a great king and warrior. He was the leader and protector of his people. “I risk my life often when I was young. Now I am old, but as king of the people I shall pursue this fight for the glory of winning…” (Heaney 2514). Even at an old age, Beowulf risks his own life for his people. This shows what a good warrior and a king would do for their people. This was Beowulf’s last fight with a sea creature and this caused great mourning throughout the country. “Mourning his loss as a man and a king” (Heaney 3172). The Geat people loved Beowulf as their king and knew there would be no one else like him. “They said that of all the kings upon earth he was the man most gracious and fair-minded, kindest to his people and keenest to win fame” (Heaney 3182). Beowulf made fame and fortune throughout his land and earned the title of a good king and warrior.
            Beowulf’s biggest flaw as a king was not having a son or child. “Now is the time when I would have wanted to bestow this armor on my son, had it been my fortune to have fathered an heir and live on in his flesh” (Heaney 2729). He left his people behind without an heir which could lead to a power struggle throughout the country. However, Beowulf was still a great king.
Beowulf characteristic of a warrior portrayed what a king should be like. He showed courage, loyalty, fame, fortune, leadership, and respect for the people. Beowulf put his own life at risk for his people to save them from the dragons. I don’t know anyone else that would have done what he did. Beowulf was a great warrior and king of the Geats.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 
Group Project
James Hogg
Condaci Crittenden
Beowulf as Warrior

C-This is Beowulf as a warrior. We are going to point out parts that portray him as a warrior that lead up to his kingship. We start where Beowulf hears about Grendel attacks in the Danes territory.

J-After I heard about Grendel I “ordered a boat that would ply the waves to sail the swan’s road and seek out that king, the famous prince who needed defenders” (Heaney 198-201).

C-This shows how Beowulf was heroic and brave. In the book it quotes “there was no one else like him alive” (Heaney 196).

J-“They had seen me bolstered in the blood of enemies when I battled and bound five beasts, raided a troll-nest and in the night sea slaughtered sea-brutes” (Heaney 419-422).

C-Beowulf has approached Hrothgar, the Dane King and lets him know why he has come and lets him know about his “awesome strengths” (Heaney 416-418).

J-I took off all my armor and laid my sword down.

C-Beowulf was very confident in his strength. He laid without his armor, waiting on Grendel to show his face at the hall. He defeated Grendel with his bare hands.

J-My “doings were praised over and over again” (Heaney 855).

C-Beowulf was looked up to as a leader and was glorified with many gifts. The Danes stated “Nowhere north or south between the two seas or under the tall sky on the broad earth was there anyone better to raise a shield or to rule a kingdom” (Heaney 855-860).

J-We were trying to show how everyone thought of Beowulf as a leader and they would have figured him to be one of the greatest kings due to all of his accomplishments that he had done up to the point he was appointed King.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 
Group Project
Britt Wilson
David Gafford
Beowulf as King

B – “The war-king planned and plotted his revenge; Beowulf their leader/ and Lord, began to plan it…” (2335-2337).

D- Beowulf plans for the battle but does not think about the consequences. He doesn’t think about the future of his people. His planning isn’t tactical because he doesn’t weigh out the options. His pride refuses to let him even think of the possibility of death or defeat.

B- “And now I shall fight for this treasure, fight with both hands and sword” (2509-2510)

D- This shows he does not fight for his people, he fights to acquire treasure. If his intentions were to guard his people he would’ve mentioned it but time and time again he mentions riches and fame.

B- “I am old now,/ But I will fight again, seek fame still, …” (2512-2513)

D- This is showing that he is still only concerned with gaining fame. He doesn’t display selflessness like a king should but is filled with thoughts of eternal fame. The desire for fame encompasses his thoughts so much that the idea of someone remembering him is more valuable than the idea of saving lives or doing what’s best for his kingdom.

B- “I risked my life often when I was young. Now I am old, but as king of the people I shall pursue this fight for the glory of winning…” (1233-1234)

D- This once again shows that Beowulf is fighting for glory and fame, not for his people. If he were fighting for his people or for anyone else but himself he would have stated that that was the reason for his going into battle.

B- “Now is the time when I would have wanted to bestow this armor on my own son, had it been my fortune to have fathered an heir and live on in his flesh.” (1238)

D- This is Beowulf’s biggest flaw as a king. He has left his people behind without an heir which could lead to a power struggle and that will have a devastating effect of the people. Even in his death Beowulf still only wants a son so that he could live on through. He doesn’t want a son to rule the kingdom and serve the people; he’s still stuck on the idea of remaining in this world after death.

No comments:

Post a Comment